Go. Just go. And suck up the long wait.
Everything on the menu is locally-sourced and delicious, and the menu varies based on the season. I got a delicious gin and cucumber cocktail, coffee, and a mushroom and egg Hollandaise concoction. My friend got the bacon rolls and oatmeal, which are apparently their most popular menu items, and also delicious.
This is hands down best brunch I've had thus far in New York, and at this point I've already been to six or seven places...
511 East 12th Street (between Ave. A and Ave B)
New York, NY 10009